Free · 13,591 studies indexed

lighttherapyresearch.com is a free index of research on photobiomodulation and light therapy, gathered from the world’s journals and trial registries.

Sections
Mental Health

A systematic review and network meta-analysis of psychological, psychosocial, pharmacological, physical and combined treatments for adults with a new episode of depression

We included 676 RCTs, 105,477 participants and 63 treatment classes.

Excerpt from the paper’s abstract. Read the full paper for the details.

AI-generated summary

The authors report a systematic review and network meta-analysis of 676 randomised controlled trials covering 105,477 participants with new episodes of depression. They found that group cognitive or cognitive behavioural therapy was associated with symptom improvement in less severe depression, while several treatments were associated with improvement in more severe depression. The authors note the evidence quality was low to moderate.

Participants
105,477
Studies included
676
Who or what was studied
Adults with a new episode of depression, analysed separately for less severe and more severe depression
Limits stated in the abstract
The authors state that evidence quality was low for less severe depression and low to moderate for more severe depression, and that the studies cover a wide range of treatments rather than photobiomodulation specifically.

Written by an AI model from this paper’s abstract only and checked automatically against it, but it can still be wrong. It is not medical advice. Read the full paper. See the editorial policy.

Abstract

Background

Various effective treatments for depression exist. We aimed to identify the most effective first-line treatments for new episodes of less and more severe depression (defined by depression scale cut-off scores), to update NICE guidance on the management of Depression in Adults in England.

Methods

Systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) published up to June 2020 (PROSPERO registration number CRD42019151328). We analysed interventions by class and individually. The primary efficacy outcome was depressive symptom change (expressed as standardised mean difference [SMD]). The review for this outcome was updated in November 2023.

Findings

We included 676 RCTs, 105,477 participants and 63 treatment classes. For less severe depression, group cognitive/cognitive behavioural therapy (CT/CBT) class was efficacious versus treatment as usual [TAU], the reference treatment for this population [SMD -1.01 (95% Credible Interval [CrI] -1.76; -0.06)]. For more severe depression, efficacious classes versus pill placebo (reference treatment for this population) included combined individual CT/CBT with antidepressants [-1.18 (-2.07; -0.44)], individual behavioural therapies [-0.86 (-1.65; -0.16)], combined light therapy with antidepressants [-0.86 (-1.59; -0.12)], combined acupuncture with antidepressants [-0.78 (-1.12; -0.44)], individual CT/CBT [-0.78 (-1.42; -0.33)], mirtazapine [-0.35 (-0.48; -0.22)], serotonin and norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors [-0.32 (-0.43; -0.22)], tricyclic antidepressants [-0.29 (-0.50; -0.05)], and selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors [-0.24 (-0.32; -0.16)]. Additional treatments showed evidence of efficacy at the intervention level. Evidence for less and more severe depression was of low and low-to-moderate quality, respectively. In the 2023 update, group yoga and self-help without support emerged as efficacious for less severe depression. For more severe depression, combined group exercise with antidepressants emerged as efficacious, whereas combined light therapy with antidepressants failed to remain efficacious.

Interpretation

Group CT/CBT (and possibly group yoga and self-help) appears efficacious in less severe depression, whereas antidepressants do not show evidence of effect. Combined antidepressants with individual CT/CBT, acupuncture and, possibly, group exercise, individual psychological therapies (behavioural therapies, CT/CBT) alone, and antidepressants alone appear efficacious in more severe depression. Quality of evidence, cost-effectiveness, applicability and implementation issues also need to be considered when formulating clinical practice recommendations. FUNDING: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence.

Abstract reproduced under the CC BY license. Source: PubMed, a service of the National Library of Medicine.

How to read a single study: what to check before relying on this kind of research.

Terms in this paper: Depression, Systematic review, Meta-analysis. Each links to its definition in the glossary.

A summary of published research, not medical advice. One study rarely settles a question. See the disclaimer and how to read research.

Related studies